Where SIEM Misses, MDR+R Steps In
How MDR+R Fills SIEM Gaps for Compliance and Protection
SIEMs are often seen as essential to a modern security stack, especially when compliance auditors and insurance providers want to see where customers comply.
For MSPs, though, a SIEM comes with delayed alerts, heavy upkeep, and storage costs that climb with every log. Here’s what a SIEM does well, where it falls short, and how Blackpoint’s MDR+R fills the gaps for compliance and protection.
What is a SIEM?
SIEM stands for Security Information and Event Management. SIEM systems integrate data from diverse sources across an organization’s environment, collecting information for processing and analysis to alert on security events and serve as a system of record for compliance purposes.
SIEM systems are a prominent piece of modern security stacks, and within that, they’re often seen as the center of analysts’ world. This single pane of glass provides a unified view of an organization’s cybersecurity health. As a result, SIEM is often seen as an essential tool for managing complex cybersecurity data and responses.
Understanding SIEM: Its Capabilities & Limitations
SIEMs do a lot well, but they also have gaps that matter to MSPs. Here are the capabilities that make a SIEM useful, and the limitations that hold it back.
Key Capabilities of a SIEM
Log Aggregation, Analysis & Storage
The ability to aggregate data from multiple sources, correlate it to detect patterns or anomalies, and store it efficiently for future analysis is crucial.
Threat Detection
Detection and response are critical parts of a SIEM, alerting security analysts to events in their environment.
Identification of Known Threats & IoCs
Threat detection in SIEMs often focuses on known bad behavior, such as malware, signatures, and indicators of compromise (IoCs). This activity easily triggers alerts based on volumetric changes in the environment’s behavior.
Dashboards & Reporting
SIEMs make it easy for analysts to intuitively understand and interact with stored data.
Log Accessibility
SIEMs serve as a system of record to support forensic analysis after a breach. This lets analysts review what happened and potentially identify root causes.
Compliance Reporting
Insurance providers and compliance auditors work with risk analysts to use SIEMs to understand where customers comply with various frameworks: CMMC, HIPAA, etc.
Limitations of a SIEM
Catching the Unknown in Time
Since SIEMs process alerts after event correlation is complete, alerts often arrive with a noticeable delay, allowing threat actors to succeed. In addition, true positives can get drowned out by the high volume of alerts.
Requires Large Amounts of Configuration & Management
SIEMs require ongoing support to ensure that data sources are configured, that data is flowing (data feed fidelity is key), and that alerts and actions based on the analysis are set up correctly.
Data Dependency & Cost Concerns
Although SIEMs enable comprehensive attack analysis, their effectiveness hinges on complete data access. However, storing every log can become prohibitively expensive because pricing models scale quickly with increased storage. With 78+% of global MSPs expecting to increase their revenue in the next three years (Datto), they cannot be bogged down by dramatic spikes in data storage pricing.
Dependent on Additional Security Tools
MSPs that use SIEMs often need other security tools to “clean” and reduce the data sent into the SIEM, increasing businesses’ spending on security stack tools.
SIEM vs. MDR+R: How MDR+R Fills SIEM Gaps for Compliance and Protection
While SIEM systems provide significant log-management capabilities, they are insufficient for MSP security. They were neither built for nor priced for MSPs.
MDR+R stands for Managed Detection, Response, and Remediation. Blackpoint’s MDR+R identifies advanced threats, responds, and neutralizes malicious activity on your behalf.
Blackpoint advocates for an integrated approach that combines the robust detection and alerting capabilities of advanced MDR with the comprehensive data capabilities of SIEMs. Our solutions offer not only compliance and advanced threat detection but also real-time, automated response that meets the needs of MSPs and their end clients efficiently and effectively.
Traditional SIEM-based Managed Detection and Response (MDR) services often fall short in several areas. Here is how MDR+R fills each gap:
| Feature | SIEM | MDR+R |
|---|---|---|
| Alerts | Often delayed, because alerts are processed after event correlation is complete | Threats detected as they happen, in real time |
| Response | Often requires manual intervention | The SOC responds on your behalf, with no manual approvals and no escalation queue |
| Threat Detection | Often focused on known bad behavior, with a high volume of alerts and false positives | Detects the enumeration, credential abuse, and lateral movement that precede a breach |
| Setup and Upkeep | Complex and time-consuming to configure, deploy, and maintain | LogIC collects logs in less than 5 minutes, and the MDR provider manages the detection logic |
| Compliance | Supports compliance reporting against frameworks like CMMC and HIPAA | LogIC maps logs to HIPAA, CMMC, PCI DSS, and CIS Controls v8 and generates audit-ready reports |
| Log Storage | Pricing models can escalate quickly with increased storage | 365 days of free, encrypted log storage, with extended retention available |
1. Delayed Alerts: Real-Time Detection & Response
SIEMs can delay alert generation, hindering real-time threat response. Blackpoint’s SOC uses proprietary technologies and human threat hunters to detect threats as they happen, in real time.
2. Manual Intervention: A SOC That Responds for You
Effective response often requires manual intervention, complicating the coordination across different tools and systems. With Blackpoint, there are no manual approvals or escalation queues. The SOC responds on your behalf to contain threats before they spread.
3. Complex Threat Detection: Detecting Attacker Behavior
Many SIEMs struggle to identify advanced or sophisticated threats, leading to high alert volume and many false positives. Blackpoint detects the enumeration, credential abuse, and lateral movement that precede a breach, with the goal of stopping attacks, not just generating alerts.
4. Deployment & Maintenance Challenges: Logging Without the SIEM Overhead
SIEMs can be complex and time-consuming to configure, deploy, and maintain. Blackpoint’s LogIC (Logging with Integrated Compliance) is a streamlined SIEM alternative for MSPs. Logs can be collected in under 5 minutes, and the MDR provider manages the detection logic, so your team doesn’t need to tune anything.
5. Compliance & Log Storage: Built-In
LogIC automatically maps logs to frameworks such as HIPAA, CMMC, PCI DSS, and CIS Controls v8, and generates audit-ready reports. It includes 365 days of free, encrypted log storage, with extended retention available for requirements such as HIPAA.
MSPs Need More Than a SIEM
A SIEM is valuable for aggregating logs, supporting compliance reporting, and giving analysts a system of record. But it wasn’t built or priced with the MSP in mind, and it leaves gaps in alert speed, response, setup, and storage costs. For MSPs, the stronger path is getting both logging and active protection from a provider built for them.
Blackpoint closes those gaps with MDR+R, where the SOC detects threats in real time and responds on your behalf, and LogIC, which handles logging and compliance reporting without the SIEM overhead. MSPs get compliance coverage and active protection from one provider.
Ready to elevate your cybersecurity strategy?
Download our CIS Controls slick sheet today and discover how Blackpoint can help you meet stringent compliance requirements and protect against sophisticated cyber threats.
DATE PUBLISHEDApril 18, 2024
AUTHORBlackpoint Cyber
SHARE ON
The Cost of Waiting
What Identity Attacks Cost the MSP
Stolen credentials don't trip alarms. Once an attacker is authenticated, they look like anyone else, and most tools aren't watching what happens next. Learn what closing the identity response gap looks like: how identity attacks happen, where response slows down, and the questions to ask any ITDR vendor.
*Identity-based techniques play a role in nearly 90% of incident investigations